Don Kirchner: Hacksaw Ridge' pays tribute to war heroes

Well, I went to see the movie "Hacksaw Ridge." Unbelievable. I kept touching my arm, wondering why I'm here. For my father was in that battle, and I don't know how Dad made it through it.

Well, I went to see the movie "Hacksaw Ridge." Unbelievable. I kept touching my arm, wondering why I'm here. For my father was in that battle, and I don't know how Dad made it through it.

My father, George H. Kirchner, was in the 307th Infantry of the 77th Division on Okinawa. He was in the battle for the Maeda Escarpment, also known as Hacksaw Ridge. The movie depicted it just as my father had described the battle to my brother and me when we were kids, climbing up nets and ladders and finding hell on earth upon reaching the top. Dad told us about Desmond Doss and his heroics.

A few years later, for some reason the St. Paul newspaper printed an article about Doss, complete with the story of the battle and a then-current picture of Doss holding his Medal of Honor. Dad exclaimed, "That's the guy I was telling you about!" He cut out the article and placed it in his copy of "Ours to Hold It High: the History of the 77th Infantry Division in World War II."

Dad is listed on the roster on page 510 of the book: Kirchner, George H, E 307.

Dad is now 91 and in excellent health.


It looks like Mel Gibson and the filmmakers did their research. The escarpment was just as Dad had described it and as his book showed it. Of course, literary license probably was necessary. For example, the Banzai attack and the resulting hand-to-hand combat actually took place at night. For visual purposes, I assume, the film staged it in the morning. Missing, therefore, was the psychological impact of the bells. The enemy wore little bells on their belts, and when that mass started running toward you, the sound at night of all those bells must have been frightening. Dad said, "You heard the bells, and you knew they were coming." I suppose they thought the Americans would turn and run. Wrong!

Also, Desmond Doss was not wounded at that battle. He was wounded late in the Okinawa campaign. Otherwise the film appeared to be historically accurate.

Lest you think that the graphic scenes of dead bodies were hyperbolic, no. Dad said that it's a smell you'll never forget.

The end of the movie made me cry a little. They showed a quote of Desmond Doss. "The real heroes are those who never came back." That's exactly what Dad has said from my earliest memories: "I am no hero. The heroes are those who never came back."

I talked to my brother and sister and suggested that we shouldn't invite Dad to see the movie. I don't know that he'd want to. But even if he did, there's no reason to drag up these realistic memories from the past that he put behind him, married, raised and spoiled us kids, and lives a good, productive life even at 91. I remember talking to his best friend and cousin, Clarence Kirchner. Dad came home, and Clarence asked him, "Pretty rough over there, Bud (Dad's nickname)? "Yup" was the answer. That was it. They never talked about it. And lest you think that Dad often talked about it, no. Only when we were kids, and only a couple of times.

I encourage everyone to see the movie. Yes, there are graphic battle scenes. But the movie goes through Desmond Doss' childhood, the love story with his wife, his struggles in training being a conscientious objector who wanted to serve, unarmed, as a medic in battle, and even old footage of his having the Medal of Honor bestowed by President Truman and excerpts of interviews.

Thank you, Dad, for your service, and thank you to all who have served. And a special thanks and remembrance to the heroes who never came back.

What To Read Next
A combined organization will ensure Minnesotans continue to have access to innovative, equitable, high-quality care close to home — now and in the future.
We were able to accomplish a lot over the years by working collaboratively between legislators, local officials and citizens.
At the Department of Employment and Economic Development’s Office of Broadband Development, we’re working hard to get broadband to more Minnesotans who need it.